Saturday, September 3, 2016

Blessings and Curses

(Deuteronomy 27:1 - 28:68 )
Then Moses and the elders of Israel charged the people, “Obey all the commandments I have given you this day.  When you cross the River Jordan and enter the land Jehovah your god is giving you, set up some large stones and coat them with lime plaster.  Write on them the whole body of the law, this after you have crossed the river to enter the land Jehovah your god is giving you, a land flowing with milk and honey, as was promised your ancestors by Jehovah your god.  When you have crossed the River Jordan, set up these stones at Mount Ebal and coat them with lime plaster, as I am commanding you today.

“You must then build there a stone altar to Jehovah your god.  Do not work the stones with iron tools, but construct the altar only of undressed stones.  Use it to make your burnt offerings to Jehovah your god.  You should also make your peace offerings and have celebratory feasts before the altar of Jehovah your god.  You must clearly write on these stones all the words of this law.

Moses and the Levite priests proclaimed this to all the people of Israel, “Be silent and listen!  This day, O Israel, you have become the people of Jehovah your god.  You must therefore obey the words of Jehovah your god and follow his commandments and decrees that I have given you this day.”

On the same day, Moses commanded the people, “When you have crossed the River Jordan the following tribes will stand on Mount Gerizim and pronounce blessings to the people: Simeon, Levi, Judah, Issachar, Joseph, and Benjamin.  The following are the tribes that will stand on Mount Ebal and pronounce the curses: Reuben, Gad, Asher,  Zebulun, Dan, and Naphtali.  The Levites shall announce in a loud voice to the men of Israel:

‘Cursed be those who carve or cast an idol and secretly sets it up.  Such works of craftsmanship are an abomination to Jehovah.’  And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’

‘Cursed be anyone who dishonors his father or mother.’ And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’

‘Cursed be anyone who tampers with a neighbor’s boundary marker.’  And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’

‘Cursed be anyone who leads a blindman astray on the road.’  And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’

‘Cursed be anyone who subverts justice for the foreigner, the orphan, or the widow.’  And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’

‘Cursed be anyone who has sexual relations with his father’s wife, for he has violated his father’s marriage bed.’  And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’

‘Cursed be anyone who has sexual intercourse with any animal.’  And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’

Cursed be anyone who has sexual relations with his sister or a half sister who is the daughter of his father or mother.’  And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’

‘Cursed be anyone who has sexual relations with his mother-in-law.’  And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’

‘Cursed be anyone who assaults his neighbor from ambush.’  And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’

‘Cursed be anyone who accepts payment to shed innocent blood,’  And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’

‘Cursed be anyone who does not accept and obey every word of these laws.’  And all the people will reply ‘Amen!’”

“If you faithfully obey the voice of Jehovah your god and carefully keep all the commandments that I have given you today, Jehovah your god will exalt you above all the nations on the earth.  All these blessings will be showered upon you and remain with you if you obey Jehovah your god.

“Blessed will you be in the city and in the country.

“Blessed will you be in your children, in the produce of your land, and in the increase of your flocks and herds.

“Blessed will you be in your harvests and in your stores of grain.

“Blessed will you be when you enter this life and when you depart from it.

“Jehovah will conquer your enemies when they rise up against you.  Though they may attack you from one direction, they will be made to scatter in seven.

“Jehovah will bless your storehouses and will bless all that you undertake.  He will bless you in the land that he, Jehovah your god, has given you.  As he promised he would,  Jehovah will establish you as a people sacred to him, provided you obey the commandments of Jehovah your god and follow his ways.  And when all the peoples of the world will come to see that you are under the protection of Jehovah, they will  respect you.  Jehovah will grant you abundance and prosperity, in your children and in your livestock and crops, within the land Jehovah your god promised he would give your ancestors.  Jehovah will open the celestial dome and from his rich storehouse, will send you rain in season and bless all that you put your hand to.  You will lend to many nations, but borrow from none.  Jehovah will put you at the head and not in the rear.  And if you heed the commands of Jehovah your god I have given you this day and follow them, you will always be at the top, never at the bottom.  You must not deviate in any direction from any of the commands I am giving you today, and you must not follow and worship other gods.

“However, if you fail to obey Jehovah your god and carefully follow his commandments and the decrees I am giving you this day, these curses will fall upon you and overwhelm you:

“Cursed will you be in the city and in the country.

“Cursed will you be in your harvests and in your stores of grain.

“Cursed will you be in your children, in the produce of your land, and in the increase of your flocks and herds.

“Cursed will you be when you come into this life and when you depart from it.

“Jehovah will inflict upon you curses and confusion and thwart all that you put your hand to until, because of the evil you have done in forsaking him, you will be entirely destroyed and quickly perish.  Jehovah will make disease cling to you until he has wiped you off the land you are going in to possess.  Jehovah will strike you with debilitating illnesses, fever, inflammation, scorching heat and drought, blight and mildew.  These calamities will pursue you until you perish.  The skies above will be like bronze and the ground beneath you, like iron.  Jehovah will turn the rain that falls into powder and the dust will pour down from the heavens until you are exterminated.

“Jehovah will cause you to be defeated by your enemies.  You will attack your enemies from one direction, but flee from them in seven.  You will be scattered among all the nations of the earth.  You corpse will provide food for the birds of the sky and the beasts of the earth to scavenge; there will be no one to shoo them away.  Jehovah will afflict you with the boils of Egypt, tumors, scabs and itches from which you can never be cured.  Jehovah will afflict you with insanity, blindness, and derangement.  At noon you will grope about like a blind man in darkness.  You will not succeed in any of your endeavors; you will be continually robbed and persecuted and no one will save you.  You will become betrothed and your future wife will be raped by another man.  You will build a house, but will not have the opportunity to live with in it.  You will plant a vineyard, but not begin to enjoy its fruit.  Your cattle will be slaughtered before your eyes, but you will eat none of it.  Your donkey will be stolen from under your nose and will never be returned to you.  Your sheep will be given to your enemies and there will be no one to get them back for you.  You sons and daughters will be sent as slaves into another land; you will strain your eyes searching for them, but you will be powerless to recover them.  A people unknown to you will eat the produce of your land and reap the fruit of your labors.  You will be constantly oppressed and continually frustrated.  You will be driven mad by what you see.  Jehovah will afflict your knees and legs with painful boils that will not heal; they will spread from the soles of your feet to the top of your head.

“You and the king you have chosen to rule over you Jehovah will exile to a foreign land unknown to you or your ancestors.  There you will worship other gods, of wood and stone.  You will become an object of disgust and mockery among the peoples where Jehovah will banish you.

“You will plant seed in the field, but little of it will you harvest, for the locusts will devour it.  You will plant vineyards and cultivate them, but you will not drink the wine or harvest the grapes, because worms will eat them.  There will be olive trees throughout your land, but you will anoint yourself with its oil, because the olives will drop off prematurely.  You will father sons and daughters, but they will not belong to you, for they will become slaves.  The insect will take over your trees and the crops of your field.  The foreigner who lives among you will rise higher and higher as you sink lower and lower.  He will lend to you, but you will not lend to him.  He will be the head and you the tail.

“All these curse will come down upon you; they will pursue and overtake you until they destroy you, because you did not obey Jehovah your god and follow the commands and decrees he gave you.  They will forever be a sign and warning to you and your descendants.  Because you did not serve Jehovah your god joyfully and wholeheartedly while you enjoyed good times, in hunger and thirst, nakedness and deprivation you will serve the enemies Jehovah has inflicted upon you.  He will put an iron yoke round your neck until you are destroyed.

“Jehovah will bring against you a distant nation from the ends of the earth that will swoop down upon you like an eagle, a country whose language you do not understand, a hard-hearted people that will show no respect for the elderly or pity for the young.  It will consume the young of your livestock and the crops of your land until you are destroyed.  It will leave you no grain, no new wine, no grapes, no calves of your herd or lambs of your flock so that you will starve.  They will lay siege to all the towns of your country until the high walls upon which you have relied for your security will fall.  They will besiege all the cities in the land Jehovah your god is giving you.

“Because of the hardships your enemies will inflict upon you during the siege, you will consume your own offspring, the very flesh of the sons and daughters Jehovah your god has given you.  Even the most soft-hearted man among you will show no compassion, not to his own brother or his beloved wife or his surviving children, nor will he share with them the food he is eating, the flesh of his own children, for there will be nothing else to eat because of the horrible deprivation the siege will inflict upon all of your towns.  The most refined and delicate woman, one so delicate she would not let the sole of her foot touch the ground, will not share with the husband she loves or with her son or daughter.  She will secretly devour her afterbirth and her new-born child, for there will nothing else to eat due to the horrible deprivation the siege will inflict upon all of your towns.

“If you do not carefully follow the words of the law inscribed in this record and revere the glorious and awesome name of Jehovah your god, then Jehovah will inflict upon you and your descendants, extraordinary plagues that are severe and prolonged, and illnesses acute, chronic and lingering.  He will bring upon you all the diseases of Egypt that you dreaded and there will be no relief from them.  Jehovah will inflict upon you every illness and plague in existence, even those not mentioned in this book of laws, until you are wiped out.  Once as numerous as the stars in the sky, you will become few in number because you have not obeyed Jehovah your god.  Just as Jehovah found it pleasing to make you prosper and multiply, he will take delight in bringing you to ruin.  You will be uprooted from the land you are to enter and occupy.  Jehovah will scatter you among all the peoples from one end of the earth to the other.  There you will worship gods of wood and stone that neither you nor your ancestors have known.  There, among these nations you will find no peace, no place to rest your feet, but Jehovah will give you an anxious mind, failing eyesight, and a dispirited heart.  You will live in constant dread both by night and day, never sure of your survival.  In the morning you will lament, ‘If only it were evening!’ and in the evening, “If only it were morning!” Your heart will be filled with dread and your eyes will be horrified by what they see.  Jehovah will send you back in ships to Egypt by a route he promised you you would never have to see again.  There you will offer yourselves for sale to your enemies as male and female slaves -- but none will buy you!”

Notes
1. Moses enjoins the Israelites to write the entirety of the law they have been given on stones.  First of all, as has often been observed, the Israelites would have been preliterate, there only Egyptian hieroglyphics and Mesopotamian cuneiform being the only available means of writing.  The stones would have be undressed, that is, rough and unfinished.  It is specified that no iron tool be used upon them.  Moses lived during the Bronze Age; it is unlikely that the Israelites at that time would have had access to any iron tools, so the prohibition seems pointless.  Plastering the stones would have provided a smooth surface upon which to write, but not, one would think, an archival surface.  Compared to the magnificent monuments erected by the great bronze-age civilization, this all seems very shabby indeed.

2. Mount Ebal and Mount Gerizim are adjacent peaks in the area of biblical Shechem and the later Nablus, 30 miles north of Jerusalem in what is now the West Bank.  Ebal is over 3000 feet high, 200 feet higher than Gerizim.  It consists mostly of limestone that was quarried considerably in ancient times.  The limestone would have furnished the material for the lime plaster that is referenced.  Archaeological excavations there have revealed what may have been altars.  Interesting that Ebal, the mountain of curses, is higher than Gerizim, the mountain of blessings.  Also interesting is the fact that Moses knew so much of the geography of the Promised Land, which he never saw nor would see.

3. The Israelites are hardly offered much of a choice by Jehovah.  He has ordained them as his people and there’s nothing they can do to get out of it.  The blessing he offers them would seem sufficient to secure to ensure their allegiance, but the curses would seem to make any act of disloyalty unthinkable.  Since Deuteronomy was written during the time of the Babylonian Captivity, the author probably included curses that may have resembled events that had come to pass during that period.  Among the religious of most creeds misfortunes and disasters are usually attributed to immorality, insufficient piety, or improper worship. 

4. The curses are very telling of Jehovah’s character.  As a master it is hard to imagine anyone more cruel, sadistic, and tyrannical, for it is with admittedly fiendish delight that Jehovah devises the harshest, most disgusting punishments imaginable for his people, if they disobey him.  He kills off the Israelites a half dozen times in a half dozen ways.  He even has them starving and resorting to cannibalism, eating their own children.  Dwelling so much on the horrific curses and bragging about the pleasure he would have in inflicting them, the Jehovah of Moses reveals himself -- again -- to be nothing less than a depraved, murderous psychopath, surely more the embodiment of evil than good.

First Fruit Offerings and Tithes

(Deuteronomy 26:1 - 26:19)
“When you have entered the land Jehovah your god is giving you as an inheritance, when you have taken possession of it and settled in it, then you should take the first fruits of the crops you harvest from the land Jehovah your god is giving, put them in a basket, and take them to the place that Jehovah your god has designated as a place of worship.  Present yourself to the officiating priest and tell him, ‘I proclaim to Jehovah your god that I have now entered the land he has swore to our ancestors that he would give us.’  The priest will then accept the basket from you and place it upon the altar of Jehovah.

“You must then declare before Jehovah your god, ‘My ancestor was an Aramean nomad who went to live as an alien resident in Egypt.  When he arrived, his family was small, but it would become a large and mighty nation.  The Egyptians, though, maltreated us and made our lives miserable, subjecting us to hard labor.  We appealed to Jehovah, the god of our ancestors.  He heard our cries and saw our toil, our misery and oppression.  With his might and power Jehovah produced horrendous acts of terror, miracles and wonders and brought us out of Egypt.  He led us to this place and presented us with this country, a land flowing with milk and honey.  Now I bring to you the first fruits of the land that you, Jehovah, has given us!’  Set down the basket on the altar of Jehovah your god and prostrate yourself before it.  Afterwards you, along with the Levites and the foreigners living among you, may make merry and celebrate the bounty Jehovah your god has bestowed upon you and your household.

“When you have finished paying the tithe on all your produce in the third year (the year of the tithe) and giving it to the Levites, the resident aliens, the orphans, and widows so that they may eat their fill in your towns, then you shall declare before the altar of Jehovah your god, ‘I have removed the sacred portion from my house and according to the instructions of your commandments, I have given it to the Levites, the resident aliens, the orphans and widows.  I have not deviated from any of your commandments, nor have I forgotten any of them.  I have not eaten any of the tithe while I was in mourning, or removed any of it while I was ritually impure, nor have I made an offering of it to the dead.  I have obeyed Jehovah my god.  I have done all you have commanded of me.  Look down from Heaven, your holy habitation, and bless your people Israel and the country you have given us as you promised our ancestors you would do, a land flowing with milk and honey.

“Jehovah your god commands you this day to follow these decrees and regulations and to obey them faithfully with all your heart and soul.  You have declared here today that Jehovah is your god, that you will follow his ways, keep his commandments and statutes, and heed what he tells you.  And Jehovah has declared to you that you are his people and will be his treasured possession as he has promised and that you must obey all his commandments.  If you do, he will set you above all the other nations he has created.  He will grant you praise, honor, and fame.  You will be a nation that is sacred to Jehovah your god, as he has promised you.”

Notes
1. Here Moses reiterates briefly the story of the Israelite people.  That Jehovah freed the people from bondage is always the rationale for the necessity of the Israelites obeying everything Jehovah tells them.  They have, in fact, traded one master for another.  Instead of being a servant of the Egyptians, they are servants of Jehovah.  It is moot question which was the more demanding taskmaster.

2. The tithe (always a tenth of the harvest) was given every third year to the Levite priests, with some to go to the indigent, widows and orphans and foreign residents.  One wonders what happened to the needy on non-tithe years, did they starve?

3. The quid pro quo of Jehovah’s relationship with the Israelites is restated -- follow all my laws, do what I tell you to do, worship me as a god, and I will shower all manner of benefits upon your nation.  Jehovah is in many respects like the lord of the manor and Israelites, serfs.

4. This concludes Moses sermon/speech to the Israelites.  It is amazing a dying man was capable of delivering such a long speech, especially since he was so oratorically challenged that he needed someone else (Aaron) to speak for him.  The speech, as has been noted many times, included anachronistic references and advice that the Israelites would not need for hundreds of years.

Thursday, July 21, 2016

More Regulations

(Deuteronomy 24:5 - 25:19)
“If a man is newly married, he must not be drafted into the army or be obligated to perform any public service.  He should be free to spend a year at home to be happy with the wife he has just wed.

“Do not accept a pair of millstones, not even an upper millstone, as security for a debt, for that would be taking away a person’s livelihood.

“If anyone abducts and enslaves a fellow Israelite or sells him, that person must be put to death.  In that way the evil among you will be purged.

“In the case of defiling skin diseases, take care to follow the instructions of the Levitical priests.  You must do exactly as I have commanded them, keeping in mind what I did to Miriam during the passage out of Egypt.

“When you make a loan of any sort to a neighbor, do not enter the man’s house to receive what he is offering you as security, but wait outside until he brings it to you.  If it is a cloak and he is a poor man, do not keep it overnight, but return it to him before sunset so that he can sleep in it.  He will be grateful and you will have done what is right in the eyes of Jehovah your god.

“Do not exploit a worker who is poor and needy, whether he be a fellow Israelite or an alien residing in one of your towns.  Pay him his wages at the end of the work day, for he is poor and is counting on it.  Otherwise he may complain about you to Jehovah your god and you will be guilty of a sin.

“Parents must not be executed for the crimes of their children, nor children for the crimes of their parents.  Each must be executed only for his own crimes.

“You must not subvert the justice due a resident alien or the orphan, or accept as security for a debt the garments of a widow.  Always remember that you were once slaves in Egypt and that Jehovah your god freed you from bondage; that is why I give you this command.

“When you harvest your fields and leave a sheath behind, don’t go back for it, but leave it for the foreigners that live among you, the orphans, and the widows, and Jehovah your god will bless you in all your endeavors.   When you pick the olives in your orchards, do not go over the vines a second time, but leave some olives for the foreigners, orphans, and widows.  And when you pick the grapes in your vineyard, do not strip the vines, but leave some grapes for the foreigners, orphans, and widows.  Remember that you were once slaves in Egypt; that is why I command you to do this.

“If two people have a dispute, they should take it to court, with the judge deciding who is in the right and who is in the wrong.  If the person in the wrong deserves a flogging, the judge should order him to lie down, and then he should be flogged in the judge’s presence with the number of lashes appropriate to the crime.  Never, however, should more than 40 lashes be imposed, for that would publicly degrade your fellow Israelite.

“Do to muzzle an ox [to prevent it from eating] while it is treading down the grain.

“If two brothers live together and one of them dies without having a son, the widow should not remarry outside of the family.  It is the duty of the surviving brother to marry her and have intercourse with her.  The first son they have should be named after the dead brother so that his name will not pass away in Israel.  However, if the brother will not marry his brother’s widow, she should go to the elders of the town and tell them, “My brother-in-law refuses to allow my husband’s name to be perpetuated in Israel and will not perform his duty as my husband’s brother.”  The elders should summon the brother-in-law and speak to him.  If he continues to refuse and tells them, “I do not want to marry her,” then the widow should approach him in the presence of the elders, remove one of his sandals, spit in his face, and declare, “This is what happens to a man who refuses to build up his brother’s house!”  And his house shall be called in Israel, “the house of the unsandaled man.”

“If two Israelite men get into a fight and the wife of one of them tries to rescue her husband by reaching out and grasping the testicles of the man who is beating her husband, you should cut off her hand, showing her no pity.

“You should not carry in your bag two different weights, one heavy, one light, or have two different measures in your house, one large, one small.  Accurate and honest weights you must have, so that you may prosper in the land Jehovah your god is giving you.  Jehovah your god detests anyone who does such things and anyone who does not conduct honest business dealings.

“Never forget what the Amalekites did to you when you came out of Egypt.  They attacked you when you were tired and fatigued and picked off those who lagged behind with no fear of God.  Therefore, when Jehovah your god gives you refuge from your enemies in the land he is giving you as an inheritance, you must exterminate the Amalekites and erase the memory of them from under the heavens.  Do not forget this!"

Notes
1. Exempting newly married men from military service seems a humane practice, not inconsistent with modern policy of sometimes giving married men or men with children draft deferments.  It provides as well an inducement to marry.  Societies have nearly always encouraged marriage, both to provide social stability and to perpetuate the race through children, who can be most successful reared within a stable marriage.

2. In Israelite society most individuals made flour for bread using their own hand mills to grind the grain they have harvested from their own fields.  To confiscate a millstone would be tantamount to depriving someone of food.

3. Enslaving an Israelite was a capital offense, but no mention is made of the morality of enslaving a foreigner.

4. The subject of skin diseases, some of which may or may not be accurately described as leprosy, is covered extensively in the Books of Moses.  Why something medical in nature should be under the purview of the priests is curious.  Medical doctors were probably unknown in Hebrew society at this time, even if in places like Egypt medical knowledge and practices were surprisingly advanced.   So it is likely that priests were sought out for health advice.  But the important aspect of skin afflictions seem to be their affect upon ritual purity, an obsession in Levitical law.

5. There are several provisions mandating kindly treatment of the the poor and downtrodden and making some allowances for the needy.  (These seem consistent with Christian charity.)  One puts a limit on the number of lashes an offender can be flogged.  Apparently 39 lashes is OK, but 40 will degrade the recipient.  A line, of course, must be drawn somewhere, but one wonders whether the age and physical condition of the person flogged, as well as the seriousness of the crime, should be a consideration in determining the proper number of lashes to be meted out.

6. The declaration that individuals should be punished only for their own crimes is very much at odds with previous statements supporting the concept of collective and ancestral guilt.

7. Not muzzling the oxen that tread the grain (apparently the standard means of threshing the grain, that is, separating the grain from the chaff) could be interpreted as exemplifying the principle of rewarding those who work, even animals.

8. The obligation of a man to marry his brother’s widow strikes one as a primitive, tribalistic custom that seems a contradiction to the prohibition in Leviticus against marrying a brother’s widow.  The exception here is if the deceased brother has no children.  This is called Levirate marriage and in not unique to Hebrew society.  Its purpose is generally to preserve marriage within the tribal unit.  The bizarre ceremony of the sandal is called halizah.  The widow must perform this ceremony before marrying anyone else, or be deemed an adulteress.  Orthodox Jews still perform this ancient ceremony when circumstances warrant.

9. The prohibition against a wife interfering in her husband’s fight by grabbing the testicles of his opponents is perhaps the most bizarre and ludicrous passage in the Bible.  Do wives generally throw themselves into the middle of fist fights or brawls their husbands engage in?  Are they usually present when such encounters occur?  And how on earth would a woman position herself during a fight so that she would be able to seize one of the combatant’s testicles?  Who is it that is in a position to cut off her hand -- a judge, when the matter comes to court?  And why are her actions, that of a loyal wife trying to defend her husband, so objectionable that they deserve no pity?  How could this provision have any practical value as a guide to behavior?  Perhaps it is meant symbolically.  Perhaps it means that a woman should not interfere with her husband’s quarrels with other men. 

10. There is another call for genocide against the detested Amalekites, the arch enemy of the Israelites and later a symbol for evil.  These were a nomadic people who lived in south Canaan, in the Negev.  They were supposedly the descendants of Amalek, a grandson of Esau, but were spoken of in Genesis as existing long before Amalek was even born.  The term is applied vaguely in the Bible, and it is impossible to pinpoint who exactly the Amalekites were and when and where they lived.

Remarriage of Divorced Wife

(Deuteronomy 24:1 - 24:4)
“If a man marries and is displeased with his wife when he discovers she is unchaste, he may draw up a bill of divorcement, present it to her, and banish her from his home.  If, after leaving his house, the woman marries another man and the second husband also draws up a bill of divorcement, presents it to her, and banishes her from his home, the first husband may not remarry her, for she has been defiled -- to do so would be an abomination in the eyes of Jehovah.  You should not tolerate such a sin in the land that Jehovah is giving you for an inheritance.”

Notes
1. The question of divorce is rarely addressed in the Old Testament.  The conditions referenced here as a basis for divorce are ambiguous.  There are two conditions stated: firstly, the husband has to be displeased with his wife and desirous of being rid of her and, secondly, there must be a fault with the bride.  A lack of chastity seems to be suggested by the text, but it is possible that other faults might be included, ill health, physical deformity of some kind, perhaps even an inability to have children.  The divorce would seem to be more akin to an annulment.

2. The husband draws up a bill of divorcement, that is, he prepares some sort of legal document, something down in writing.  The society of Moses, the people listening to this sermon, would not have been literate.  It seems a stretch that personal legal documents would have used until many centuries later, after the invention an alphabet and the Hebrew language.  But most of Moses’ sermon is anachronistic in this regard, pertaining to social conditions that would only exist many centuries in the future.

3. It is perhaps surprising that the divorced woman is free to marry again.  Would she, though, have been stigmatized, regarded as a dishonored woman?

4. There is no suggestion that a woman could ever divorce a man irrespective of cause.  But this is hardly surprising considering the second-class status women had in Hebrew society.  (Women didn’t fare much better in other ancient societies until the Romans, who, at least at a later period, granted women greater rights.)

5. Why a man remarrying a former wife constitutes a sin is hard to determine.  The second husband does not sin by marrying a defiled woman that once belonged to another man, then why should the first husband remarry a woman that is already defiled?  The rationale seems somewhat obscure.

6.  Jehovah only seems concerned about what sins are perpetrated in the land he is giving the Israelites.  He doesn’t want his land polluted. (It’s always all about him!)  It seems he could care less about sins committed in foreign lands, even by Israelites.  He is rather like a landlord who polices his property to ensure that behavior of which he disapproves does not occur, but he is unconcerned about what his tenants may do off the premises.  The welfare and moral character of his people is only important in so far as it impinges upon Jehovah’s plans and impacts Jehovah’s pride.

Thursday, June 30, 2016

Further Regulations

(Deuteronomy 23:15 - 23:25)
“If an escaped slave has taken refuge with you, do not return him to his master, but let him live with you without persecution in whatever town he may choose.

“Israelite women or men are forbidden to become temple prostitutes and the fees that such persons may earn may not be used as payment for any vow in the house of Jehovah your god, for both are abominations to him.

“You may not charge interest to fellow Israelites, whether on money, food, or anything that might be loaned on interest.  You may charge interest to a foreigner, but not to a fellow Israelite, so that Jehovah your god may bless all your undertakings in the land you are entering to take possession of.

“If you make a vow to Jehovah your god, do not delay in fulfilling it, for he will require it of you and, failing to do so, you will be guilty a sin.  However, if you make no vow, no sin is committed. But be careful to do what you say, if you have made a voluntary vow to Jehovah your god.

“When you pass through your neighbor’s vineyard, you may eat your fill of grapes, but you must not take any away in a basket.  And when you pass through your neighbor’s field of standing grain, you may pick some kernels with your hand, but you must not reap the crop with a sickle.”

Notes
1. The provision to shelter runaway slaves is an interesting one, hardly conducive to the perpetuation of the institution of slavery, of which Jehovah has never expressed any disapproval.  If there is no legal obligation for fugitive slaves to be returned, then the incentive for slaves to escape is great.  Therefore, one would think this provision would result in considerable social disruption, however humane it may seem to us.  It would be surprising if this passage was not cited when 19th century Americans were dealing with the problem of fugitive slaves.

2. One way in which Jehovah separates himself from his rival gods is his rejection of practices such as prostitution and “sacred” intercourse within the temple.  Such practices may have been widespread in the ancient world, in Greece and Rome as well as Babylonia and other Middle Eastern countries, but there is no consensus among historians as to its extent.  Prostitution was rarely condemned by ancient cultures or regarded as immoral per se.  The biblical references are obviously to the religious practices of the neighboring Canaanites, but there is no real evidence for the existence of temple prostitution in early Palestine.  The authors of the Bible had an interest in portraying their enemies in the worst possible light and using their immorality as a justification for Israel’s aggression against them.

3. The Old Testament prohibition on charging interest is curious, since the descendants of the Israelites would become notorious as moneylenders (one of the few professions the medieval Christians, conforming to this regulation, would allow the Jews to engage in).  It highlights the hallmark of tribal mentality, two different set of rules, one governing relationships within the tribe and another governing relationships with those outside it.  While foreigners dwelling among the Israelites are, in many ways, treated with equality, here we see an example of disparate treatment and of how foreigners might be exploited by Israelites.

4. It is made clear that not to fulfill a vow made to Jehovah is a sin, but that to renege on some promise not made explicit, a mere statement of intention, or some vow made perhaps to someone other than Jehovah, would not qualify as a sin.

5. Taking a few samples from a neighbor’s vineyard or field is held as permissible, not stealing, while collecting grapes in a basket or actually harvesting the grain is not.  This is quite in line with tradition and indeed, English common law.       

Cleanliness in Camp

(Deuteronomy 23:9 - 23:14)
“When you set up camp while waging war against your enemies, avoid anything that is ritually impure.  If one of your men is ritually impure because of a nocturnal emission, he must remove himself from camp for the day.  He should stay away from camp until evening when he is to bathe himself, returning to camp at sunset.

“Establish a designated area outside of camp to be used as a latrine.  Each man should have as part of his equipment a shovel so that when he urinates or defecates he can dig a hole for that purpose, then cover it up with dirt.  The camp must be kept holy because Jehovah your god moves about in it as he protects you and defeats your enemies.  He does not want to be exposed to anything indecent -- or else he may turn away from you!”

Notes
1. Jehovah continues his micromanagement of Israelite affairs, apparently thinking that his Chosen People are too stupid to figure out it needs to make a place where soldiers can relieve themselves.  The reason for it, though, seems less for the sake of the Israelites than for Jehovah, who wants to make sure he will not offended by any unsanitary conditions.  The Victorian dictum “cleanliness is next to godliness,” has its corollary here, “cleanliness (in the sense of maintaining ritual purity) is part of godliness.”  And there is the threat that if Jehovah does not find everything squared away in camp, he will abandon the Israelites -- a rather petty threat for a presumed god to make.

2. Surely there is a certain impracticality in the rule that a soldier must absent himself from camp for a day if he has a nocturnal emission (colloquially, a wet dream, literally, an involuntary ejaculation occurring during sleep).  One can imagine the scenarios.  “Where is Captain Nehemiah?  Why isn’t he attending our meeting of officers to discuss our strategy to defeat the Canaanites?  Oh, he had a wet dream last night and won’t be able to come back to camp till after sunset.” or “Why can’t Benjamin perform guard duty today?  He got out of it by saying he’s ritually impure because he supposedly had a nocturnal emission last night.” and “We don’t see much of our sergeant in camp these days.  He keeps having wet dreams!”  The situation seems patently ludicrous and one unlikely to further troop morale or personal dignity, being, at least to modern sensibilities, an embarrassing intrusion upon one’s privacy.

Thursday, June 2, 2016

Those Excluded from Jehovah's Congregation

(Deuteronomy 23:1 - 23:8)
“No one whose genitals have been crushed or cut off may join the congregation of Jehovah.   No one born illegitimately may ever became a member of Jehovah’s congregation nor may his descendants even for ten generations.  No one who is an Ammonite or a Moabite or their descendants even to the tenth generation may join Jehovah’s congregation, for their nations did not welcome you with food and water when you came out of Egypt.  Instead they hired Balsam son of Beor from Pethor in Aram to curse you.  (Jehovah your god did not heed Balaam, but turned his curse into a blessing, because Jehovah your god loves you.)  Throughout your history, you must never promote their prosperity or make a treaty with them.  But you should not abhor the Edomite, for he is your relation, or the Egyptian, for you were resident aliens in their land.  Children from the third generation of them may become members of Jehovah’s congregation.”

Notes
1. It seems rather cruel and unfair that if a man suffers an accident adversely affecting his private parts then he’s no longer allowed to be a part of Jehovah’s congregation, or, in modern terms, to worship in church.  This provision may have been directed toward religious devotees who willfully emasculated themselves, such as the worshipers of the ancient Phrygian god Attis.  But this would seem to condemn castration for any reason.  (Hebrew society had no place for eunuchs, who, nevertheless, were a part of many Asian cultures.)  The early Christian church, though, expressly accepted as members men who had been emasculated.  Jesus himself, in Matthew, ambivalently suggests castration to avoid submitting to carnal desires that might lead to sinful sexual behavior.  Some Christian zealots have put this into practice.  (An interesting example is the American Civil War soldier Boston Corbett, the killer of Lincoln assassin John Wilkes Booth.  Perhaps unbalanced by inhaling poisonous fumes while working as a hatter, he became a religious fanatic.  One night in 1858, while walking home from church, he was propositioned by a couple prostitutes.  Disturbed by the encounter, he sought guidance from the Bible and found a solution by severing his private parts with a pair of scissors.)  --- The castration of boys to maintain a high singing voice was practiced in Europe from the 16th Century.  It was only condemned by the Catholic Church in the 19th Century; Italy did not make this abominable custom illegal until 1870!

2. The exclusion of those of illegitimate birth from Jehovah’s congregation is consistent with the policy of keeping only those who are “impure” from worshiping Jehovah.  Just as animals sacrificed to Jehovah must be without blemish so must the worshipers be without physical imperfections.  That no one has no control over the circumstances of his birth or the morals of his parents is not considered.  Children paying for the sins the fathers is well established in Jehovan law.  Punishment creates a deterrent to bad behavior; however, in this case, it is not the guilty but the innocent upon whom the weight of punishment falls.

3. Moabites and Ammonites are also excluded from worshiping Jehovah because they, or their ancestors did not treat the Israelites with hospitality during the Exodus.  Moreover, they hired the prophet Balaam to curse them.  The Moabites and Ammonites are apparently to be regarded as permanent enemies.  Jehovah eschews the modern notion of “permanent interests, but no permanent enemies.”  The United States of America, for instance, has never held historic grudges; it has a habit of establishing friendship with almost every country it has fought a war against, England, Mexico, Spain, Germany, Japan, even Vietnam.  Jehovah, though, if anything, is a vindictive god who has no desire to make friends of enemies.

4. Egypt, surprisingly, is given something of a pass.  The grandchild of an Egyptian could become a full-fledged Jehovah worshiper.  This, because the Israelites lived in their country.  Indeed, but they were slaves there -- what favors were owed the Egyptians?  The Edomites were also granted some leniency since they were relatives.  (The Edomites were descended from Esau, Jacob’s elder twin brother.)  It should be pointed out that the Moabites and Ammonites were fellow Hebrews as well, being descended from Lot, Abraham’s nephew. 

5. Aram, here Aram Haharaim, “of the two rivers”, is usually placed in an area including northern Mesopotamia and Syria and what is now southeastern Turkey.  This area would have been the kingdom of Mitanni during Moses’ time.   However, it is more likely that the Aram of the Bible, the home of the Aramaeans, was a much smaller area in southern Syria north of the Golan Heights, not in Mesopotamia, where Arameans may have later settled.